One Door Down

This is a minor rewrite of my story by the same name. Recently I read it again and noticed some minor errors that I missed in my previous final edit when I posted this two years ago. While re-editing this I tried to improve the wording in a few places and elaborated a bit more in some scenes.

=====================================

"You promised me, Jim!"

Betty was begging now, tears welling up in the corners of her emerald green eyes. While nibbling on her nipples to distract her Jim had gently slid his rock-hard member down her naked stomach until it slipped between her thighs. His tip was sitting right at the junction, ready for action.

Betty groaned with the feeling, but added "Don't do it. I told you so many times!"

Jim smiled at her before he responded.

"You want this as much as I do. I can see in your eyes! You just orgasmed on my tongue, you are so wet and so ready."

He could not resist the temptation when there was no immediate response. Gently he rubbed the tip of his iron hard member up and down at the junction of her naked thighs, feeling the wetness between her lower lips. This got a deep groan of desire out of Betty, which he, without thinking, took as permission. Quickly he slipped the tip between those lips, feeling her heat. Her moisture promised an easy entry. Her heat on his glans, the moisture of her lips, just one plunge and she would be his.

"No Jim, no!"

"But you let me undress you, kiss you. You kissed me back with abandon. And now being skin to skin with you is driving me insane. I want to make you mine."

"No Jim! No! Stop! I told you from day one, my pussy belongs to my husband. I'll kiss you; I will be naked with you, I'll give you a hand job or blow job, but you cannot have my pussy. It belongs to my husband."

Despondently Jim looked down at this gorgeous woman he had been trying to seduce for the last few months, ever since he moved in next door from where she lived. Luckily for Jim her husband was away a lot and Betty was a woman who loved attention and needed it regularly. Since he worked mostly from home as a copywriter he had been able to pay her the attention she wanted. It started with going over for a morning coffee, doing small chores, or watch the occasional Netflix movie together at his place.

Slowly they had become amazingly comfortable with each other, Jim taking care not to show his desire for her too openly. Sometimes her husband was away for several weeks at a time. Slowly they spend more and more time together when he was away. During those periods it became almost as if they were married, except they were not. And every night each would sleep in their own bed in their own house.

The affection developed slowly. In the beginning it was just hugs with a chaste pecks on cheeks. Then the hugs became deeper and longer, the kisses less chaste, the groping more frantic. Betty gave him a hand-job after a movie night with too much wine, and a blowjob a week later. Recently she road herself to an orgasm on his lap with his hand on her pussy while both had their pants on and tops off. Sucking her nipples pushed her over the edge.

For Jim, Betty was his type of woman, petite, long curly red hair, true red as proven by the landing strip above her otherwise hairless cunt. He finally confirmed this a two months back when they got into their first naked make-out session. Green eyes, freckles, luscious white skin, and somewhat small but firm breasts that he really got to fondle and kiss at the same time when he found her landing strip. She was 38, looking like 31, slender, trim, cute as a button, and unfortunately married. And she wanted to make that marriage work in spite of the make-out sessions with Jim whenever her husband was away.

And now here Jim was, so close to fulfilling his dream, nestled between her stunning legs where he had managed to manoeuvre himself during the make out session today on his bed. She had even pulled up her knees when he had rolled on top of her with his dick on her belly. Slowly he had slid down while kissing her deeply. And now finally the tip of his dick was nestled between those wet pussy lips he had been licking earlier. Just one push and he would be in!

Would she accept that? Or would he never see her again if he did. Unfortunately for Jim he was also a man who would never force a woman! A promise was a promise. That is why she let him undress her, why they had gone as far as they had today after several weeks of blow jobs and finger orgasms.

Keeping his gaze locked on her he pulled back out so he was just touching here.

"Ok, but promise you will stay here just like this! I will be right back. Promise?"

Betty nodded with a sigh of relief.

Within thirty seconds Jim was back, and kneeled again between her splayed legs, showing her a tube of lube. He opened it and applied it liberally to his still extremely hard member.

"What are you doing, Jim"

"If I cannot have your pussy, I want this" he responded, putting a big dollop on his middle finger, and applying it to her puckered anus.

"Can I please, please make your back door mine?"

"What?"

"I want you so much! It drives me insane!"

"I have never done that, my husband never even mentioned it. He is happy with my pussy."

Betty squirmed a bit as Jim's finger entered her nether hole guiding in the lube.

"It is almost like the real thing, its is a close as you will ever get without breaking your promise. And it would make me incredibly happy. Let's do it one door down! Let's try."

Betty blushed, hesitation flitting across her face. She also saw the desire in Jim's eyes. He wanted to make love to her, fuck her, and she wanted to make him happy. The feeling of first one finger in her bum, and then two, actually felt not that bad. Slowly Jim added more lube, sliding his fingers in and out.

"Will you be gentle, it scares me a bit" Betty responded after a minute of having her backdoor fingered.

Jim smiled. "Of course! And you can always tell me to stop."

Then he quickly applied some extra lube to his rock-hard member and stretched himself on top of Betty. Carefully he kept his weight on his arms while slowly guiding his penis between her thighs until he was rubbing his glans again at the very top junctions of her thighs.

"Can you grab me and guide me to the right place, Betty. I don't accidentally want to take your pussy when I push in. If I ever get completely in there I don't think I can stop until I come."

Betty smiled somewhat fearfully before closing her eyes, reaching down with her right hand to guide Jim one door down. He felt so big and hard. It took some determination from her to hold him in place while he gently applied pressure. To her surprise she felt herself yield, felt how the head slipped in, rubbing against her inner sphincter. Jim waited a few seconds and then with a gentle push Jim was past that barrier as well.

Betty eyes opened wide as she let go. Slowly she wrapped her arms around Jim's neck.

"Oh wow, it really got in" she whispered. "No more anal virginity for me!"

Jim smiled. "Thank you for giving me that!" Adding "Rub your pussy, it will help you relax and make it truly a new experience."

Then he leant over to kiss her while keeping his dick in place. He guessed she need to get used to him before he went any deeper. It was very tight, and he knew he needed to take it slow. That was ok with him, he finally was going to make Betty his!

Adding a bit of pressure he slowly went somewhat deeper. Now he knew, she was going to be his, there was no stopping him now. They were going to make real love! To Jim it felt almost as if he was in her pussy, just a bit tighter. He waited almost a minute before he gently applied more pressure and felt himself enter ever so slightly more, maybe an inch or more. Again he stopped and slowly laid himself down on top of her, taking Betty into his arms. It did not take long before their kissing and body movements became as if they were making regular love. The only difference was that Jim took a long, long time to enter her.

With gentle strokes he nudged deeper and deeper into her, giving her time to adjust when needed. But persistently he kept going until he was more than halfway in her. If you could have looked at them from the side they looked just like a couple making normal pussy love. He lifted his head breaking the kiss, and Betty opened her eyes.

"How do you like it so far? Does it hurt?"

"It is a bit weird, it hurts a bit, but I love the intimacy. It is almost like making regular love, especially in this position. And it is wonderful we can do this without me breaking my promise to my husband. He would never understand, but that's ok. This way I can be all yours now as well!"

"Yes, I want you to be mine. I love that I can see your face, your freckles, that I can kiss you while making love to you, fucking you!"

Jim nudged deeper and in response Betty lifted her legs and wrapped her ankles around Jim's hips, curling her bum up to take him in deeper yet, giving herself to him as he was giving himself to her.

"Make love to me, fuck me, so I will be yours and you will be mine" she groaned. "But do it fast, with my fingers on my clit I can come almost anytime now!"

Jim needed no further encouragement, with a few firm strokes he rammed all the way in, slapping his testicles against her upturned bum. Betty's groan was both pain and pleasure, but there were no objections. Jim pulled halfway out and then started fucking her in earnest, feeling the pressure in his balls rise quickly to the point of explosion. Betty undulated under him, fucking back with a passion, following his every move while at the same time vigorously rubbing her pussy.

It took only twenty or so firm strokes, just enough time for Betty to rub her clitoris to her own point of orgasm. As she started her slide into pleasure Jim plunged himself to the root into her bottom and started shooting is sperm deep into her. Ropes and ropes of cum were shot deep into her. Both of them reached out for an open mouth kiss while they trembled together in orgasm, Jim moving in and out in short movements, almost as if in despair, while Betty tried to push herself onto him as deeply as possible. It was intense and felt like it lasted a long time. They both moved together until the last waves, the last drops, until slowly, slowly they relaxed, breaking the kiss for need of more air.

"Wow, that was amazing" Betty managed to get out. "A much better way to lose a virginity than the pussy one I lost at seventeen."

"That means your butt is mine now. No sharing with anybody," Jim said with a grin. He gently moved in and out to make sure everything remained gentle, until with a final squeeze from Betty he slipped out.

"Yes, I am yours like this. We have to do it again after my hubby leaves in two weeks" Betty admitted with a purr. "But my pussy remains off-limits!"

Jim nodded, but then added "If you find out that your hubby shares his dick on his trips, does that mean your promise to him no longer holds? Maybe we should find out what he does when he travels?"

"We will see, I have really no idea about that. But you are right, if he has broken his promise, I can break mine. And I will break it if I ever find out he did. Then my pussy can be yours too!"

"So there is hope yet!" Jim added with a grin.