Gift of Moving On

Chapter 7 - Twas the Night Before...

After my second shower of the day, I start dinner. Traditionally, we do pasta, meat sauce, and a salad on Christmas Eve while I do a bit of prepping for our more formal Christmas dinner. With Lexi napping, Izzy assists me with prepping our XMAS dinner.

"You wear Lexi out?" Izzy teases.

"No, she is regrouping," I tell her as I peel and chop potatoes.

"So do tell... You two must not have been in her bed. I couldn't hear anything for the longest time, then I heard her screaming."

"We were on the other side of the room," I say, keeping it vague.

"I got myself all worked up for nothing," Izzy jokes.

"Sorry to disappoint."

"Not that I heard anything until the end, but it didn't sound like you disappointed.

"I just wish I could hear what all that sudden screaming was about."

"You'll, ummm, have to talk to her about it."

"That's so unlike you, Dad."

"I know. I just don't have words at the moment."

"Is everything okay?"

"Yea, everything is okay...

"It's just, we did something different. I'm probably making it a bigger deal right now than I should be. I just... Am not real comfortable talking about it, that's all."

"Is Lex okay?"

"Yea, she is... I think.

"You can wake her up and talk to her if you'd like. Dinner is almost ready and she wanted woke up for dinner."

"I can do that," Izzy says as she goes to wake her sister. The both of them emerge from Lexi's room in time for dinner, with Lexi dressed in an oversized hoodie and sweatpants.

As I put the potatoes away and finish throwing together dinner, I reflect on how uncomfortable that short conversation was for me. 'How exactly do I word things to one daughter, that I am fucking, that I just had mind-blowing sex with her sister... my other daughter... and that I stuck it in her ass?' I think to myself.

I get that Izzy knows about Lexi, although Lexi does not know about Izzy... Izzy and I have been very open with one another, which in part has made things as hot as they are between us. But I'm having a real hard time being THIS open with her... Probably because it would sound just so fucking naughty if I heard the words coming out of my mouth as I spilled the tea.

Dinner came and went... We went over the plans for tomorrow. I get up bright and early to cook. The girls get up when they get up. We exchange a single gift before dinner and the rest after. While nothing juicy came up in conversation, I suspect Lexi filled Izzy in, as she through in a little zinger on how she rescued me in my shopping endeavor, making sure everyone got what they wanted rather than leaving me to fend for myself - where my choice in gifts would have become the butt of all household jokes.

On a more serious note, Izzy mentions that her friend will be coming a day earlier to pick her up to go back to school. As such, she'll be leaving on Saturday morning. Her friend will arrive on Boxing Day in the afternoon, weather permitting and will spend the night before the two of them hit the road.

I clean dinner up before settling in on the couch for evening tv rather than finishing my prep for tomorrow's dinner. Both of the girls decline my offer of drinks, so I drink alone it seems. Lexi immediately cuddles into me on the couch under a shared blanket while Izzy plays on her phone. I note that while Lexi is cuddly, she is not her usual talkative, playful self as she sits curled into me, my arm around her.

I tested the waters offering a foot rub, which she declined. I even got a bit 'handsy' under the blanket to no avail. My efforts only served to get me slightly worked up. While Lexi didn't fend off my efforts, she certainly did not reciprocate in any sexual manner. She did, however, remain cuddled into me unflinchingly.

When Izzy got up to use the bathroom, I asked Lexi if everything was okay. She shared that she just wasn't feeling too hot, assuring me there was nothing to worry about.

Our movie ends and I suggest it is time for me to head to bed, citing an earlier than normal start due to cooking. I kiss both of my daughter's goodnight before retiring to my room.

About twenty minutes pass before my door cracks open with Lexi peeking in.

"Still awake?" she asks.

"I am."

"Can I sleep with you tonight?" Lexi asks.

"Of course you can. No need to ask," I assure her as she closes the door behind her and pads her way to the bed. I pull the covers back and scoot over, making room for her to lay down.

Still in a hoodie and sweats, Lexi cuddles into me - her head on my chest and my arm around her.

"You sure you're okay, kiddo?"

"Yea, I just feel a little... full, I guess. From earlier. Sorry..." Lexi replies.

"Hey, there's nothing to be sorry about," I tell her as I kiss her on top of the head.

"Just so you know, If what we did earlier today hurt you, we don't ever have to do that again. I wasn't expecting we did that in the first place, but we don't ever have to..."

"It was what I wanted to do. I figured with the oil, it wasn't going to hurt," Lexi says, cutting me off.

"I want to do that again. Not now, obviously... But I want to try that again for sure. I want to do everything with you, Dad," Lexi says as she kisses my chest.

"I like making you feel good and I REALLY like feeling good together with you. I love sharing my body with you and I guess I just want to do that all the time," Lexi says as her hand finds its way overtop my boxers to my cock.

"Yea, but Lex... You know I don't ever want to do anything that hurts you," I reply as my cock begins to grow.

"I know you don't and that's one of the many reasons why I love doing these things with you," she says as she fishes my hardening cock out through the hole in my boxers.

"Lexi, I love that you enjoy making me feel good and I love making you feel good too," I respond.

"But, with you not feeling well, we don't NEED to do anything. We can just cuddle if you're not feeling up to it."

"I know. That is all the more reason that I love doing this with you," Lexi says as she slides up and in for a deep kiss.

"And I love doing this with you," I tell my daughter in between kisses while her soft hand strokes me.

As she gets me worked up, stroking and kissing me, my hands try to explore. A touch, a feel, removing her clothes. Despite my best efforts, Lexi thwarts my every attempt at getting her naked, opting instead to leave her clothes on.

"Just relax and enjoy," my daughter tells me.

"I need to keep my clothes on so we don't accidentally end up having sex."

"What if I promise you that we won't?" I ask as I pull at her hoodie.

"Will you also promise not to touch me back there?"

"Promise," I answer as her hoodie comes off, my mouth immediately lunging for her breast as my hand slides below her sweats.

As we continue pleasuring each other, Lexi slides her sweats down.

"What if I changed my mind?" she asks, feeling hot and bothered.

"A promise is a promise... No matter how badly I want to break that promise right now...

"And trust me, I REALLY want to break my promise. You're making Daddy feel so good right now and your tight little pussy is so wet and hot... Daddy would love to be inside his baby right now," I tell my daughter as I tease her pussy with my fingers.

"Dad, please..." Lexi begs as she wraps her leg around me as we toy each other side by side.

"We can't Lex... I promised..."

"Fuck, I'm so close... I NEED you inside me, Daddy... You. so... don't... understand..." Lexi begs, battling to get me inside her as I continue rubbing her hot pussy.

I kiss my daughter hard, in part to gain control - pushing her onto her back, knowing her orgasm is near.

"How about if Daddy goes down there?" I ask as I begin sliding down her hot little body - kissing along her neck, down her chest, rubbing her clit.

"Uhhhhhh... No, no, no, no, NO... Fuck... I need you up here!" Lexi begs, pulling me up as her body tenses.

"Oh God, uhhh... Fuck... Please... Fuck me Daddy, please please PLEASE..." Lexi moans, nails in my arm, muscles clenched, pretty toes curled, mouth and eyes wide open as she cums on her Daddy's finger, begging for his cock.

I hold my thrashing daughter still, arm around her as waves of her orgasm crash in on the shore.

Little by little, my fingering slows down as we tenderly kiss.

"Feel better?" I ask as my hand leaves her pussy. Lexi smiles and nods.

"Your turn now," she tells me as her hand finds her Daddy's cock once again.

"Lexi, I'm good... Plus, I owed you one from earlier!" I add.

"I still want to make you cum, Daddy... You're still so hard."

"Plus, I still kinda want you inside me," Lexi pleads as she rubs my cock.

"We can't, Lex... I promised."

"I'm not going to stop until I make you cum," Lexi says as she strokes me.

"How about we compromise?"

"Compromise?"

"You promised me no sex. But I am not going to stop until I make you cum and I want my Daddy to do it inside of me," Lexi says as she works my cock.

"So how about if you put it in me just once, to get it nice and slippery...

"And I rub you while you're part way inside of me?

"Please, Daddy?" Lexi begs, weaponizing her seductive brown eyes, rubbing her smooth leg and foot along my leg, pleasuring my cock with her hand... Placing me under her spell... Making it incredibly difficult to turn her down.

"Lexi, I gave you my word," I tell my little temptress of a daughter, fearful that once inside, we're not going to have the self-control to stop.

Lexi pulls me in for a deep kiss as we lay side by side, bodies tangled, her leg wrapped around me, her small hand around my cock, one of my arms around her, the other tenderly touching her face.

Breaking the kiss, Lexi guides me to her slender neck, which I gladly kiss while she masterfully works my cock.

"Dad, do you remember at the hotel - before we had sex, I got my hand nice and lubed up...

"And I put my hand around your Daddy cock...

"And you got on top of me...

"And fucked my hand while we made out?" Lexi asks in a seductive voice as I kiss her neck.

"I remember."

"That was so hot, wasn't it?" Lexi asks as I feel her very slowly, sneakily rolling onto her back and trying to pull me on top of her.

"It definitely was," I agree as I continue kissing and nibbling on my daughter's neck.

"It would be kinda like that...

"Only this time, you'd be a little bit inside me..." Lexi moans as she rolls flat on her back and has managed to coax me almost on top of her - straddling one of her legs, my cock in her hand, my hips moving in sync with her story as I kiss along her neck, one arm around her, the other planted on her breast, finger circling, teasing her erect nipple.

Totally under her spell, my daughter makes me an offer that I cannot refuse.

"Slide over a little more," Lexi instructs, coaxing me just a little further between her legs.

"Daddy, feel that..." Lexi begins as she rubs the tip of my dick along the webbing of her warm, wet, pink slit.

"She wants you, can't you tell?" Lexi says as she rubs my dick up along her pussy while I clamp down on her neck.

"Doesn't that feel so good Daddy?" Lexi moans, tracing circles around her clit with the tip of my dick while jerking me.

"Mmmmm, it does," I moan.

Lexi realizes she is beginning to win this battle, as I bite down on her neck, my hand desperately moving along my daughter's hot, young body.

"I can tell you're close...

"I am too," Lexi says as my heart begins racing & my breathing quickens while she pleasures us both.

"I know you want to cum, Daddy...

"Don't you want to cum for your daughter?

"IN your daughter?

"Inside your daughter's hot, wet, tight pussy?"

"Oh my God, Lexi... This is torture," I moan, trying to resist.

"All you have to do is stick it in me once...

"And we can both explode..."

"Fuck, Lexi..."

"Daddy, don't you want to make your daughter cum?"

"I do..."

"Don't you want to feel your daughter cum?

"Her wet. Tight... Little... Pussy cumming on, cumming with her Daddy's dick?"

"Oh fuck... Yes!" I groan, knowing my orgasm is so very near.

"Then Daddy, all you have to do is put it inside...

"I know you want to...

"Let me help you," Lexi says as she slides my dick toward her opening, as I subconsciously slide between her legs.

"There you go... Good...

"Daddy, you're so close..." Lexi says as I feel her insides barely around my tip, my daughter's pussy calling to me, trying to draw me in.

"I'm so close..." Lexi moans as she releases my cock from her tiny hand, sliding it up ever so slightly to toy with her clit.

"We're... So... Close..." Lexi whines as she tangles her legs around my calves, rocking her hips underneath me, tickling the tip of my dick while working her own clit.

"Daddy... Daddy... Daddy, please! Just put your dick inside me one time..." Lexi begs, working her clit faster and faster.

"I want. To cum... On... Uhhhh! MY DADDY'S... DICK!!! UHHHH FUCK!!!!!!!" Lexi says as her back arches and toes curl.

Unable to hold out any longer, I take the plunge - forcefully thrusting my dick into my daughter's pussy as waves of her orgasm pulse throughout her tense, hot, flailing little body.

Planking overtop her, cock buried inside, I enjoy the beautiful sight of my angel, my baby girl, my daughter cumming on her Daddy's dick while her hips thrash, her body twitches, back arches toes curl, eyes roll back, lower lip bit, tight pussy contracting upon her Daddy's dick.

As my daughter's orgasm seemingly rocks her world, the beautiful sight, combined with the sensation of my daughter cumming on her Daddy's dick buried deep inside brings about my own orgasm - my daughter's pussy milking her Daddy's cock as I tense and go numb, exploding in unison with my youngest daughter, collapsing on top of her as we cum together.

I roll us to our side, my cock still buried inside, Lexi's legs wrapped around me as we cuddle.

"Just to be clear, I kept my promise. We did NOT have sex," I tell my daughter as we unwind.

"We totally did not," Lexi replies, catching her breath and holding me tight into her, as I glance at the clock.

"Technically, I made that promise yesterday, as it is a little after midnight... So even if we did, a little bit, I kept my word for the day," I add.

"Agreed...

"Oh, ummm... Merry Christmas Dad..." Lexi says as she smiles.

"Merry Christmas, beautiful," I reply, kissing her gently on the cheek.

"Hey Dad," Lexi says, pausing until my eyes lock with her beautiful browns.

"I love you," my daughter tells me before giving me a playful, yet sensual peck on the lips.

"Lexi... I love you too," I tell my daughter, looking her in the eye as she hugs me tighter and pulls me in for a passionate kiss.

My daughter and I spent the next hour or so talking, kissing, caressing, and yes - fucking. Our conversation started with Lexi clarifying she both loves her Daddy and is in love with her Daddy.

As we rolled so she was on top of me, I shared with my daughter that I clearly loved her and was falling in love with her.

I had to roll us so that I was on top of her and in control of the majority of our body movements, as there was zero chance of prolonging our session if Lexi remained on top.

We continued talking, agreeing patience and time were key. We agreed we knew how to make things work inside the confines of the house - although we were both clueless as to how we could really make things work on the outside. We brainstormed some ideas as I moved in and out of my daughter and in between kissing and heavy petting, but we agreed we'd eventually figure out a way.

I approached naming the elephant in the room, intending to share that I'd also recently had relations with Izzy. I got as far as telling her that Izzy and I grew closer over this break before Lexi cut me off, letting the cat out of the bag and 'spoiling' her Christmas surprise for me by sharing that she got Izzy to agree to 'give our Dad a real threesome as his big Christmas present.'

Either Lexi got real excited in sharing that news... Or perhaps I got distracted and weak. Or maybe it was a combination of all the above. I let my daughter on top and she took control. The conversation ended with her riding me, both of us sitting up - making love, cumming together before drifting off to sleep.

We enjoyed one another one more time before I got up to start cooking. Lexi heard my alarm before I did, quickly shutting it off, then she dove under the covers, sucking me off until I woke up. Once awake, she jerked me with the tip barely inside her until my cock exploded, citing that my resolve last night created an obsession or fetish in her. What a way to wake up!

I got out of bed to start the Christmas meal, while Lexi curled up and went back to sleep with a smile on her beautiful face...