My Stepdaughter's Bestie

Part Seven

I haven't been able to stop thinking about all the naughty things Chloe said to me since we parted ways at the beach. The rest of the day went by uneventfully. Carol and Pauline got very drunk and I had to sit beside them and listen to them and talk about everything that happened with Pauline's break up for six painful hours.

Chloe and Leah spent most of the day on the boardwalk together. Whenever they came back, I made sure to study every curve of Chloe's body while I could.

I knew I wouldn't be able to resist her in the future. Frankly, the idea of even trying felt foolish. Chloe will only be staying with us over the summer and when she goes back to school in the fall, things will return back to normal.

Until then, I don't think I'm ready to give her up just yet. There are a lot of things I want to explore with this horny young college girl, and I plan to. The guilt might eat away at me inside, but it's a small price to pay for a pussy as perfect as Chloe's.

I hate myself for even thinking that.

It's still a holiday weekend, and I don't have any work on my plate. Carol is home and the girls are both spending a majority of their time out by the pool. I watch through security cameras to see if there's ever a chance to catch the two of them making out or grinding their pussies together again, but they don't.

It almost seems like their relationship has ended or something. It's weird. They were so hot and heavy when they first got here and now all of a sudden there's nothing. I'm curious to know what happened, but I can't very well ask if they broke up because that might clue them into the fact that I've been watching.

"I'm going to take Pauline home," Carol says, popping into my office and interrupting me as my nose is stuck in a book. "She is still so out of it after yesterday that she can't drive."

Ah, yes. Pauline was barely coherent when she eventually passed out on our couch last night. I'm not surprised she has a hangover today.

"Need me to come with you to drive you back?" I ask, bookmarking the page and setting the book down beside me.

"Thanks, but I'm going to hang out with her for a little bit at home, make sure she gets some food in her," Carol sighs. "I'll just take an Uber home."

She steps into the office and gives me a quick peck on the forehead before leaving. I sit in silence as I quietly listen for signs of her leaving. With Carol gone, I have a perfect opportunity to be alone with Chloe for a little bit. Granted, Leah is still in the picture and I don't know how I'll get Chloe away from her just yet.

I watch Carol and Pauline pull out of the driveway and I immediately wander downstairs to try and get eyes on the other girls. They're not out back anymore, but I find them sitting in the kitchen eating PB&J sandwiches.

"What are you girls up to this afternoon?" I casually ask, leaning against the counter and smiling at them both. It's hard not to notice how little clothes they're wearing. At the same time, I don't think they're trying to hide that from me.

Leah looks particularly stunning right now. She's in a tiny cropped tank top that hugs her large breasts tight enough for me to see she's not wearing a bra. I can barely make out the peaks of her nipples under the dark blue fabric. On top of that, she's in a pair of loose fitting linen shorts that show off her curvy legs wonderfully.

Chloe is in a tight fitting sundress that shows off ample cleavage while obscuring most of her curves. At the same time, her legs are on full display. It takes every modicum of strength and me not to imagine them wrapped around my waist as I fuck her harder than I ever have.

"We're just thinking about playing a game," Leah says, leaning her elbow on the table and smiling at me.

"And what game is that?"

Chloe turns and smiles at me, biting her lip playfully. "Truth or dare."

My heart skips a beat as I think about the game. Of course, I played it all the time when I was younger. When I was in college it was nothing more than a drinking game to sit back and watch as we dared girls to make out with each other.

"You should play with us," Leah adds, a devious smile on her lips.

As much as I want to say yes, I have to maintain an image for myself. "I shouldn't be playing schoolyard games at my age."

Both of them laugh and look at each other, some sort of silent communication happening between them. For the umpteenth time I'm wondering what's going on between the two of them. It's always seemed like Leah knows something about Chloe and myself. This isn't doing anything to ease those thoughts.

"Would it kill you to have a little bit of fun?" Chloe asks, leaning her elbows back on the table as she turns to face me entirely. "Come on. I promise we'll take it easy on you. We just want to get to know you a little better."

"Please," Leah says, flashing me an exaggerated pout.

I think about it for a minute. I have no idea what these two are getting at right now, but I'm intrigued. At the very least, I might get to see the two of them make out with each other. I can always decline to answer questions or do things that might get me in trouble with Carol, too.

There's a tiny voice in the back of my mind telling me this is a really bad idea. I feel like Leah has something up her sleeve right now, but the excitement in my chest is winning out. Just looking at Chloe staring at me with the expectant smile she seems to wear me down.

"Fine, I give in," I say with a shrug. Both of them let out an excited squeal then jump up from the table.

"Let's get to it!" Leah excitedly says, walking toward the basement door with Chloe behind her.

I follow them down the stairs with a mixture of excitement and apprehension in my gut. The basement was refinished a few months ago, so it's not just some creepy dark room. Carol and I turned it into a home theater of sorts. We've got a nice flat screen tv, an oversized modular sectional that we can rearrange to turn into a bed for guests. It's a nice, comfortable space to hang out in.

Chloe and Leah push the coffee table aside and sit down on the rug, messing around with the remote to play some music around us.

"How about you grab a bottle of vodka for us?" Leah asks, sitting on her knees and staring up at me with a smile. I could get used to that view.

"I don't know about that, girls," I say, shaking my head. Having a couple beers from time to time is one thing, but doing shots while playing truth or dare with my stepdaughter and her best friend is probably a very bad idea. I don't know how I'll explain that to Carol.

"Come on," Chloe says, rolling her eyes dramatically. "We're at the house, nothing bad's going to happen. Besides, you only take a shot if you don't do what you're supposed to."

By the way both of them are staring at me, it's impossible to say no. I go to the bar cart in the back of the room and grab a bottle of vodka from the minifridge. I grab three small shot glasses and sit down on the rug between them.

Chloe excitedly grabs the bottle and pours all three of us a shot. She and Chloe tap the rims of their glasses together with smiles as they look at me with devious lights gleaming in their eyes.

"Let the game begin," Leah says before downing her drink.

Leah goes first and flip a coin to choose between me and Chloe. She lands on Chloe.

"Hmm... I pick truth!" Chloe excitedly says, leaning back and biting her lip anxiously.

Leah taps her chin as she dramatically pretends to think. "How many men have you slept with?"

I feel myself starting to blush already and there's a part of me that thinks I should get up and walk away because if this is where we're starting, this is bound to get more inappropriate. But at the same time, a much more prominent part of me wants to see how this plays out.

"One," Chloe bashfully replies. Leah raises her eyebrows and laughs, but doesn't say anything else. She just hands Chloe the coin and she assigns both Leah and myself one side before flipping it. "Mark, that's you!"

"Let me think," I say, taking a deep breath and debating my best choice. Chloe could ask me something compromising and I'd have to drink to hide that from Leah. I think this early on, a dare is going to be relatively harmless. "Dare."

Chloe makes a show of looking around the room and thinking hard about a good dare. "I dare you to show us your sex playlist," Chloe says between laughs.

Leah giggles and I find myself laughing at the dare too. It's a little bit embarrassing, and weirdly vulnerable, but I figure it's mostly harmless. I pull up my phone, navigate to my Spotify and show it to them. Both of them gather around the phone and scroll through, nodding their heads at how some of the songs are actually really good.

"I don't think I've used that since college, so don't judge me too harshly," I laugh. Even then, I don't think I put most of the songs on the list.

"Candyshop?" Leah asks, raising her eyebrow at me. I can't help the nervous feeling that rushes through me knowing my stepdaughter has read about the preeminent dick sucking song on my sex playlist.

"Okay, suddenly I'm feeling like I should have taken the shot," I say, pulling my phone away from them. They hand me the coin and I flip it, landing it on heads which I have assigned to Leah.

"Dare," Leah quickly says before I even have a chance to ask.

I know what I want to dare her. I want to dare her to kiss Chloe, all the way down her body so I can watch up close and personal as she goes down on her. I want to watch the two of them undress and fuck each other while I jack off beside them and spray my cum all over their bodies.

But I can't.

"I dare you to show off the most recent picture in your camera roll," I say.

Leah isn't fazed by the Dare and she promptly pulls out her phone, opening up her camera roll and showing both of us a picture.

My heart practically sinks to my stomach when I see a photo of her in the bathroom mirror, holding a towel loosely over her body. She's smiling with her tongue out as she can barely contain her breasts under the white towel. Her pussy is only barely covered by the fabric and I can see an entire bare thigh.

"Satisfied?" Leah asks where the devious smile as her eyes move from mine down to my cock which has decided to make its presents known.

"You win," I say, promptly looking away from the photo and forcing myself to think of anything to make my dick go down. The last thing I need is Leah seeing how hard I get just at the side of her curves.

Leah grabs the coin and flips it, turning to me with a smile. "Truth or dare?"

"Truth," I promptly say, not wanting to know where there is going to go now.

"Have you ever had a threesome?" Leah asks quickly enough that I can't help but wonder if this has been on her mind. "And if not, do you want one?"

Oh God yes. I want one badly. Right now with her and Chloe.

Instead of answering her question, I grab my shot and down it.

"He has secrets," Leah whispers. "Well, Chloe, since he drank, I guess that falls to you. Truth or dare?

"Dare," Chloe says with a wicked grin. She bites her lip excitedly and waits while Leah thinks of an appropriate dare.

"I dare you to swap clothes with me for the rest of the day," Leah says.

Chloe bites her lips and looks down at her shot before standing up right and wiggling her way out of the sundress. I'm too shocked by the sudden nudity in front of me to look away, and the longer I stare at Chloe's sexy body on display, I can't hide my attraction.

Of course, she isn't wearing a bra under the dress. The only thing she's wearing right now is a pair of white cotton panties. She holds the waistband between her fingers and looks at Chloe.

"Panties too?" Chloe asks.

"Everything," Leah answers, standing up to undress.

As soon as I see Leah starting to undress, my eyes lock on her. I know how wrong this is, but I can't look away. I've thought about Leah almost as much as Chloe, and the idea of my sexy little stepdaughter getting fully naked in front of me right now makes all the blood rush to my cock. There's no point in hiding that now.

Leah takes her top off, showing me her perfect bare breasts. They're big and perky and I want nothing more than to reach out and take her hard pink nipple in my mouth. I'm practically drooling at the thought of it. Then she shimmies out of her shorts, showing off a tight lace thong she's wearing underneath. When that goes off, I can just barely notice a wet spot on her panties as she slides out of them and hands them to Chloe.

I'm still sitting on the ground, so I am eye level with both of their pussies and I can see how they're already glistening with moisture.

"Fuck," I whisper under my breath, catching Leah's attention as she slowly bends over away from me so I can see her perfect ass as she slips on Chloe's panties.

"I think he likes what he sees," Leah says to Chloe as she stands upright and slips the dress on over her head.

Chloe puts on her clothes and both of them sit down casually like nothing just happened. Every thought in my brain is practically gone and all I can focus on is how painful my boner is against my zipper right now. I want to unleash that and massage my own cock right now more than anything in the world.

Chloe grabs the coin and flips it, looking at me. "Truth or dare?"

"Dare," I say before I can think any better of it. I know where this is going. I'm not blind and I'm not stupid. I wanted to try to fight this and be as calm as I could, but after seeing that I don't think I can.

Both of these sexy college girls are sitting before me, their pussies wet from excitement, how the hell am I supposed to resist that?

"I dare you to kiss Leah," Chloe whispers, immediately followed by the most devious grin I've ever seen from her.

I look at Leah and see the excitement in her eyes. She shrugs her shoulders. "It's just a game. I promise I won't tell my mom."

I look down at the empty shot glass in my hand, knowing what I should do. I should stand up and leave the room. At the very least, I should take a shot.

"Fuck it," I say, taking a deep breath and exhaling a small laugh. "A little kiss isn't going to hurt anything."

I'm about to lean forward and give my stepdaughter a tiny peck on the lips. Before I can, Leah is on her hands and knees and crawling over to me, climbing onto my lap before I can say anything else about it. She lowers herself completely so her wet pussy is grinding against my cock through my jeans.

Her arms are around my neck as she tilts my head back and presses her lips against mine. This is not a gentle kiss by any means. The moment her tongue grazes my lips, I let go of every ounce of resolve I had.

Her lips part and I slide my tongue inside, tasting every part of my stepdaughter's sweet mouth. I explore her mouth fully, sucking on her lip and swallowing every small moan that escapes her mouth.

My hands reach for her waist instinctively to hold her closer and she bucks her hips against me to grind her pussy hard against my groin. I know she feels my cock and with how her hips move instinctively against it I know she fucking loves it.

I lower my hands to her thighs, sliding them up the skirt of the dress and grabbing her perfect ass between them.

"Ahhh!" Leah moans out as I pull her hips hard against me.

"This is so hot," Chloe says behind us.

Leah grinds herself against me as she keeps kissing, her fingers running through my hair as she refuses to let me go. In the very back of my mind, I shut off that voice telling me this is wrong. How can this be wrong? Feeling her perfect body against me like this is the closest to Heaven I might ever get.

She wiggles her hips against me, driving a moan out of my throat I could do absolutely nothing to fight against. I pull away from her and almost forget about the game entirely as I stare down at her tight body in my lap.

She bounces on me, nearly making me cum on the spot. "You like that, daddy?"

"Fuck me..." I moan hearing her call me that. She rocks her hips more to tease me before sitting up on her knees and pulling her pussy away from me.

Chloe moves in closer now and kneels right beside both of us. I feel her hand reaching for my crotch before I can fully grasp what's about to happen.

"Looks like you made a little bit of a mess, Leah," Chloe purrs, pointing both of our attention to the wet spot on the front of my jeans. Leah lifts the skirt of the sundress to show off how soaked her panties are after that.

"Sorry, daddy. Maybe we should take these off of you and clean them up?" Leah whispers, her fingers swiftly moving to the button of my jeans.

I just sit back in stunned silence as she and Chloe work together to get me out of my pants. As soon as my zipper is undone, my cock springs free and I only raise my hips a bit for them to pull my pants off entirely.

"You said he was big, but I didn't believe you," Leah whispers to Chloe.

My mouth hangs open at the comment and I look between them as realization dawns on me.

"He tastes good too," Chloe says, leaning down and nuzzling the side of my cock, her tongue falling out to taste me.

"You knew?" I manage to ask Leah. Leah just giggles and nods her head, kneeling down on the other side of me.

"Knew? I brought Chloe here for a reason," Leah whisperers, her tongue grazing against my rock hard shaft a moment later, not even giving me a second to wrap my head around what is happening.

Both she and Chloe moan as they lick my cock in unison. They're tiny pink tongues flicking out of their mouth, swirling their way up my shaft. Their tongues brush against each other from time to time and it only makes them smile.

If I ever thought I knew Heaven before, this is actually it. Seeing too sexy college girls kneeling in front of my cock, both of them using their mouth to pleasure me, is absolutely the sexiest thing that's ever happened. My eyes are on Leah as she traces her tongue from the base of my shaft all the way to the tip, pressing her lips firm against it before sucking it in her mouth.

She works a few inches of my cock inside of her mouth as Chloe flicks her tongue against the shaft, her blue eyes watching me intently.

"You like watching your stepdaughter suck your cock?" Chloe asks, licking one of my balls and teasing it. "You're such a naughty man."

Chloe moves her face to the tip of my cock and Leah pulls it out of her mouth. Both of them press their lips against my soaking wet tip, almost making out with each other just with the tip between it.

"Oh my God..." I moan, almost dizzy from the intense pleasure it brings me.

Their tongues swirl around my shaft, meeting each other mid way and tasting both of their spit mixed with my cock as they close their eyes and worship it.

Leah backs away and Chloe sucks my cock, working every inch deep in her throat as Leah sits back and smiles at me. She runs her fingers through Chloe's hair and pushes her head down more, forcing her all the way down to my balls.

I can feel Chloe gagging on me as Leah just holds her in place.

"You want to cum in my mouth, don't you?" Leah whispers. She licks her lips and moves closer to kiss me again while she bobs Chloe's head up and down on my cock.

My tongue slides in her mouth and I can taste myself on her tongue and I don't care. My fingers lace through her hair and I hold her close to me as Chloe continues going down on me.

I need to figure out what the hell is happening right now, but I don't want to stop this. Stopping this would be nothing short of a sin.

Leah backs away from me and before she can move back down to my cock, I pull the dress off of her and lift it over her shoulders, freeing her tits once again. I grab her waist and pull her close, taking a nipple in my mouth to suck on. Leah let's go of Chloe's hair and Chloe immediately pulls herself off my cock, spit dripping down her chin as she catches her breath.