Harem Master - RPG story

--- Lucy Izanami ---

After a short talk with Asher, Lucy texted on their group chat a new rule - no talking about Madeleyn's past. Before, she would have been ready to bet her ass that the blonde girl was a virgin, but after Asher's warning, Lucy had doubts.

"Okay, girls," she said, returning to the living room. "While those two lovebirds have their fun, we're going to play too."

"You remember I'm not into girls, right?" Sam asked.

"While I like where your mind went, I meant a different kind of fun," Lucy replied with a smile. "We're just getting to know each other, and it would be cool to speed up the process, so we'll play Truth or Dare."

Lucy looked around the room, trying to gauge all of the girls' reactions, and while they didn't jump excitedly, screaming that it was the best idea ever, they didn't protest either.

"What's that?" Sisi asked.

"A very simple game. Has everyone here played it before?" Lucy asked.

"I did," Sam said, but except for her, no one else spoke up.

"Seriously?" Lucy asked. "You must play it at least once in your life, and today's a perfect opportunity. Well, I assume that at least you know the rules, but I'll go over them just in case. For starters, is everyone here okay drinking?"

Everyone except Madelyn and Sisi agreed immediately.

"Asher said I shouldn't drink," the dryad said.

"He's just worried," Lucy replied. He really did worry too much, which was starting to frustrate her, though at the same time, it opened up so many chances to tease him. "If you hold back a little, nothing will happen to you. You'll just feel more relaxed and enjoy yourself. Besides, I already bought you this."

Lucy pulled out a bottle from her explorer bag and showed it to Sisi. "It's a cider. Basically, an apple juice, and Asher agreed to that."

"That's a stretch," Ava said.

"Only a little," Lucy replied with a grin. She had promised Asher that Sisi would only have an apple juice, and while that was a bit of an understatement, and he'd probably get a little angry, it would pass, and they'd still have fun. "Besides, Sisi is an adult and can make her own choices."

"Isn't it harmful?" Sisi asked, looking at the bottle.

"In very big amounts, yeah, but if you stick only to this bottle, then you'll be fine. Right, Ava?" Lucy asked.

Sisi looked at Ava, and when the fire mage nodded with her lips pressed into a thin line, the dryad took the bottle.

"Cool," Lucy replied, then looked at their blonde, shy friend. "Maddy, if you don't want to drink, it's okay, I bought some soda."

"I'll drink," Madelyn whispered.

"Cool, but you don't have to drink to play with us. No pressure at all," Lucy said, wondering if Madelyn didn't want to be the only one not drinking. But Maddy nodded again, making her choice.

"Okay," Lucy said. "Back to the game. We spin the bottle, the person who spins asks the person it points to. We don't know each other well, so it might be easy to ask about something that would make someone uncomfortable. So, if a person doesn't want to answer or do a dare, they can drink instead, and they choose what and how much as their punishment. Next, that person spins. If it lands on someone who was already in that round, it moves to the person on their left. This way everyone is asked in a round before the next one starts. At the end of every round, we drink. Again, everyone can choose what and how much. Is everything clear?"

Lucy looked again around the room. She added a few things that could kill the fun in the game to make sure that no one would feel bad, but she was hoping that with the alcohol, they would relax a bit and would do a few fun dares or truths.

"I'm not sure I understand," Sisi replied. "I mean, what are those questions or dares supposed to be?"

"That's the best thing about this game," Lucy replied. "There are no rules about what you ask. The mood is set during the game, depending on who plays it. You'll see during the game. But if you have a problem when it's your time to ask someone, just think about what you would want to know about them, and ask that. Or what would be funny to make that person do, and dare them. That's why we have rules about drinking, if you go too far, they just drink, and we move on."

"Do we put any limitations on what you can ask about?" Ava asked.

"I don't think there's a need," Lucy replied. She didn't want to mention aloud what she hoped everyone saw on their phones about Madelyn. "Again, they can refuse to answer by drinking. And seriously, it doesn't need to be much - just a sip of beer - and no one would bother anyone about it. We don't want to push anyone. We want to have fun and get to know each other better. Can we start now?" Lucy asked. She really hoped that with alcohol and the progress of the game, they all would relax a bit and stop being so worried and shy.

After everyone agreed, they moved the table out of the middle of the living room. Lucy took out beers and vodka and set them aside on the table, and after everyone picked something for themselves, they sat down in a circle.

"Cool," Lucy said, turning on music low in the background, as she grabbed a bottle of beer and poured it into a glass. "To make it work, I'll be asked first, and then spin the bottle. So, we need a volunteer who will ask me something."

"Truth or dare?" Sam asked immediately, sipping a beer.

"Truth."

"Do you regret that you're here with us, rather than there with them?" Sam asked, nodding toward Asher and Elara's room.

"Actually... no. I hope we'll have much more fun here," she answered, then grabbed the bottle and spun it. When it landed on Madelyn, the blonde girl's eyes widened, looking at Lucy.

"Truth or dare?" Lucy asked with a soft smile.

"Truth," Madelyn whispered.

Lucy wondered for a moment, it was only the first round and it was Madelyn, so she needed to choose something that would be interesting while not scaring her away immediately.

"Tell us about your class and skills. And about your team, or more precisely, are there any handsome guys in it?"

Madelyn let out the breath she had been holding.

"That's two questions," Ava commented.

"Well then, she can choose which one she wants to answer," Lucy replied with a shrug, drinking her beer.

Madelyn told them about her class and skills first. "Also, I have an all-girls team," she added, answering both questions.

"So cool!" Lucy gasped. "You'll have girls' night every night. Your turn."

After Madelyn spun the bottle, it landed on Ava.

"Truth," the fire mage said when Maddy looked at her.

There was a moment of pause as Madelyn sat in silence, and Lucy wondered if she had trouble coming up with a question already, but as her cheeks gained a little bit more color and she turned her gaze away, Lucy realized that Maddy had a question in mind but was struggling to ask it, so she gave her time, hoping it might be a fun one.

"W-Why did you agree to... to... join this..." She trailed off, waving her hand at the whole circle.

"You mean, why did Ava agree to join Asher's harem and share him with a few other girls?" Lucy asked.

Maddy quickly nodded, biting her lower lip.

"For skills," Ava replied.

"Only that?" Lucy asked.

"Yes."

"And that Asher is handsome didn't have any part in it?" Lucy asked.

"Not really," Ava replied, shrugging.

It was hard for Lucy to believe that, especially when Ava acted as if she had a crush on him.

"So, if he were an eighty-year-old, bald, wrinkled prick, would you still agree? Just for his skills?" Lucy asked.

"That's a new question," Ava said, and spun the bottle. It landed on Lucy, but as she had already been chosen in this round, it moved left until it reached Sam.

"Truth or dare?" Ava asked.

"Truth," Sam said.

"Why do you explore if your parents have so much money?" Ava asked. "You could just do nothing for the rest of your life."

"I could ask you the same question," Sam replied.

"It's not my turn," the fire mage said.

"My parents forced me to," Sam sighed. "If I didn't come here, they would cut me off."

"So, you didn't want to become an explorer?" Lucy asked.

"If I must choose something, then I choose dungeons. But I didn't have an option to do nothing, as Ava suggested," Sam explained, then grabbed the bottle and spun it. Between only Naomi and Sisi left, it was the first one's turn.

"Truth or dare?" Sam asked with a smile.

Naomi hesitated before she chose the truth.

"Oh, that might be interesting. Lifelong friends, asking for the truth," Lucy said, hoping that Sam would know exactly what to ask Naomi to get something fun or spicy out of her.

Sam thought for a moment, before she looked at Nami with a smile. "Do you want to kiss Lucy again?"

"Sam!" Naomi gasped, averting her gaze to the side when all eyes turned to her. She glanced quickly at Lucy, with a blush creeping on her cheeks. "Yeah," she whispered, before she looked away again.

"Oh, you're so cute when you blush. I want to kiss you too. Even now," Lucy replied, glad that at least one of them was interested in some girl-on-girl fun when Asher wasn't present. "We'll have some fun later on," she added, winking, wanting to see Nami blush even more. "Now, only Sisi's left. Nami, you're asking."

"Truth or dare?" Naomi asked.

"Truth, I think," the dryad replied.

"Why didn't you want to borrow clothes from us and preferred to stay in Asher's hoodie?"

"Umm... I told you. It's comfy," Sisi replied.

"Only that?" Lucy asked.

"It's true," Sisi said.

"But not the whole truth," Lucy said, squinting her eyes.

"Ugh... It's... Being here, everything is so... different from my home. And I had those dreams for over a week, and... his smell there was the same as in this hoodie, so it's at least a bit familiar. I don't know... it's... I feel safe in it, surrounded by his smell," she said, and then pulled her hoodie further on her head.

Lucy watched the dryad answer, but it caught her attention that Madelyn was absentmindedly nodding while listening to that, and she wondered if the support girl felt the same around Asher.

"Cool, now time to drink. Again, everyone drinks whatever they want," Lucy said.

Lucy approached the table and poured herself a shot of vodka. Looking around the group, Ava, Sam, and Naomi quickly joined her. Sisi poured herself a cider into the glass, while Madelyn chose a beer.

"For the girls' night," Lucy said, raising her shot and drinking. It burned through her throat, but she quickly drank beer to kill the taste. After everyone drank, they returned to the circle.

"So, how do you like it?" Lucy asked Sisi, gesturing at her drink.

"It tastes a bit like apples," the dryad replied, taking one more sip.

"Do you like it?" Lucy asked.

"Yeah."

"Perfect. Now, new round. Sisi you spin," Lucy said, then took a sip of her beer.

The dryad spun the bottle and it landed on Madelyn. "Truth or dare?" she asked, and Ava translated between them, like she had been doing since the start of the game.

"Truth," Madelyn murmured.

"Do you want to join this team?" the dryad asked.

"No!" Maddy gasped, her cheeks reddening immediately.

Lucy wanted to tease her but stopped herself and pushed the game forward to change the topic. "Straight to the answer, and now you spin."

Madelyn did it quickly, and it landed on Naomi.

"I think... dare," Naomi said.

Lucy realized that it was clever, asking for a dare from someone who wouldn't give her anything hard, and no one could accuse her of not choosing them.

"Umm... I don't know," Maddy said. "Drink a shot of vodka? Is that okay?" she asked.

"Sure," Lucy replied immediately. It would be more fun if she had to drink it from between her tits, but Lucy didn't want to discourage anyone. However, that didn't mean she couldn't joke about it. "We're too sober to dare her to do it from between my tits."

"It puts her in a situation without choice," Ava said. "If she doesn't want to do the dare, she needs to drink anyway."

"But then she can drink a sip of beer," Lucy replied, looking at Ava, who was taking the whole game and rules much too seriously.

"I'll drink," Nami said quickly, pouring and drinking one. Then she spun the bottle, and it was Sam's turn, who chose the truth.

"Oh, revenge," Lucy said, looking at Naomi. "You certainly know some of her dirty secrets."

"Actually," Naomi said, "there's something I don't know. When you were talking with Asher about joining, you said you're not interested in girls, and that you had already tried it. You never told me about it."

Sam shrugged, finishing her beer.

"With who?" Naomi asked her question.

"Do you remember that one time I went playing billiards with Daphne?"

"Yeah," Nami replied. "I thought that you didn't really meet with her, and were..." she trailed off.

"Whatever you thought I was doing, I really was playing with her. Later on, we went to her place, drank a little... Well, maybe a bit more than a little, and let's say that we spent the night in the same bed and didn't exactly sleep a lot."

"What did you do?" Lucy asked, wondering how far Sam went in her experiments.

"That wasn't part of the question," Sam replied with a smile. "You'll need to ask in the next turn."

"Do you know that Daphne?" Lucy asked Naomi, changing the target of her questions.

"Yeah, she was with us in class. I didn't know she likes girls."

"She didn't," Sam replied. "We discovered together that night that we only like men." Then she spun the bottle and it was Lucy's turn.

"Truth, and the next time, I'll go with dare," Lucy replied.

"How often do you masturbate?" Sam asked.

Lucy smiled, glad that she wasn't the only one wanting to push the game into a more fun direction. "Depends on my mood, and if I get any. Without a boyfriend, spending my whole day at home bored? Like two times? But now with Asher around, I don't do it at all."

"You do it that often?" Ava asked, sounding really surprised.

"You don't?" Lucy asked.

Ava shook her head, looking at Lucy.

"Well, it's your turn, Ava, truth or dare?" Lucy asked, without spinning the bottle as Ava was last in the second round.

"Truth," Ava replied.

"Was Asher your first? And did you come?"

"That's two questions," Ava said.

Lucy sighed. "We don't need to follow rules like they are laws. But if you really want, I can ask you to describe your first time, and you will give us answers to both of them anyway," she said, almost sure that Ava's first time had been with Asher.

"It was Asher, and yes, I did," Ava replied, staring at Lucy.

"Yeah, I would guess so. He's surprisingly good, even if he's quite inexperienced," Lucy said.

"Is he?" Naomi asked quietly.

"Yup! Not that he does amazing stuff or something, but he cares about you being comfortable and your pleasure, and he wants to make you come, but like really, really wants to do it, not only to boost his ego. He listens, is considerate, and I would say safe," Lucy said, looking at Naomi.

"Let's drink," Naomi said, running away from under Lucy's gaze, and poured herself a shot.

Lucy directed it to Naomi, but also had Sisi in mind. She would also add Madelyn as a virgin, but after Asher's warning, she wasn't sure about that anymore. But even if she had some bad past experiences, you didn't need to be Sherlock Holmes to see that there was some pull between them, and with the free spot in the harem, Lucy added Madelyn as a potential candidate to take it.

After downing her shot, Lucy looked at Madelyn and Sisi's bottles. While she wanted to have fun, she didn't want to interrupt Asher's night with some trouble. Maddy hadn't even drunk half of her bottle of beer, but Sisi was pouring herself another glass of the cider, and Lucy decided to slow her down after that one.

"Okay," Lucy said. "We kind of fucked up the order," she added, glancing at Naomi. "Someone was so eager to drink. But now Ava asks Sisi, and the second round will be finished, and we'll begin the third round without drinking."

"Truth?" Sisi asked, looking at Ava.

"What were you calling Asher when you were dreaming about him, but didn't know his name yet?" Ava asked.

"Man from my dreams," the dryad replied, shrugging.

"And that's the end of round two," Lucy said. "Round three," she added, as the dryad spun the bottle and it landed on Naomi.

"Truth."

"Do you have dreams about Asher like I do?" Sisi asked.

"No," Naomi replied immediately.

"That's a lie," Sam said.

"Oh," Lucy gasped. "Interesting."

"It's true," Naomi protested, looking at Sam.

"You told me something different," the tank replied.

"The question was if I have dreams like Sisi about him. And I don't."

"But you have dreams about him," Sam said, smiling.

"I had one," Naomi replied. "And it wasn't like that," she said, then spun the bottle. "Truth or dare?" she asked Lucy when it stopped at her.

"Dare, cutie, and make it interesting," Lucy replied.

Naomi hesitated, staring at Lucy.

"I can tell you have something on your mind," Lucy said. "Do you really think you can ask me something I won't do?"

"Show us every... umm... thing that you have in your explorer bag that's supposed to be for... you know..." Naomi stumbled over her words.

"You mean sex toys? All of them from this ring?" Lucy asked, raising her hand.

Naomi nodded quickly.

"Oh girl, do you even realize what you're asking for?" Lucy asked, smirking. "Are you sure you want to see it?"

Naomi nodded again, this time more hesitantly.

"It's your unlucky day. I have most of them stacked in another ring that I keep by my bed. But I have some here," she added, before she summoned everything that fit at least a bit - cuffs, dildo, and vibrator. Beyond that, she summoned lube and a few pieces of her lingerie, even if those weren't sex toys.

"Well, that's it," she said, with all the things displayed on the floor between them.

"Y-You have more in your room?" Naomi asked, her cheeks reddened. While Madelyn looked away, embarrassed, Sisi and Ava actually seemed interested in those items.

"Of course," Lucy replied, hiding her toys. "I'll show you later, cutie," she added, winking at Naomi. Then she spun, and it was Ava's turn.

"Dare," the fire mage said.

Lucy grinned when she heard that, pleased she could come up with something fun for Miss Stick-Up-Her-Ass.

"Fuck, can I change it?" Ava asked.

"No, but you can always drink, if you're a pussy," Lucy replied, wondering how far she could push things so Ava would actually do it rather than drink.

"What is the dare?" Ava asked.

"Make out for a minute," Lucy replied, holding back her smirk.

Ava looked at Lucy for a moment, then took a quick glance around the girls in the room, and shrugged. "With who?"

"With your fire elemental," Lucy replied.

"What?" Ava asked.

Naomi giggled, hearing the dare, hiding her mouth behind her hand when Ava glared at her.

"You can drink if that's too much for you and you can't have some fun," Lucy said, shrugging.

Ava looked at Lucy, squinting her eyes for a moment before she got up. But rather than approaching the table to drink, she stepped back, and a flame appeared in her hand that flew to the ground and grew into a fire elemental.

"Madelyn, can you count time for me?" Ava asked, glancing at the blonde.

"Okay," she replied, pulling her phone out, with her cheeks reddened.

"And don't desummon it when you are finished," Lucy added. "It might come in handy later on."

Ava didn't answer, focused on her own fire elemental, that looked like her but was made out of flames.

"I'm ready," Madelyn whispered.

Ava nodded, then took a deep breath, and at the same time, both she and the elemental embraced each other. Their lips connected, and while their kiss seemed hesitant at the start, it seemed Ava was quickly getting into it, pressing their lips together tighter, as she put her hands on the elemental's body.