Harem Master - RPG story

Hey, I'm really sorry for not posting here for so long. I'll try to upload regularly from now on, and hopefully the chapters will be coming out more quickly. I hope you enjoy this chapter and have a great time reading it.

--- Asher Montgomery ---

Asher woke up, lying on his back, with Elara draped over his body, her legs tangled between his, her head resting on his shoulder, as she traced something on his chest with the tips of her fingers.

"Morning, beautiful," he whispered.

"Hey, handsome," Elara murmured.

Asher exhaled deeply, fully rested even after the night full of sex. He wasn't even sure how many times they had actually done it, dozing off a few times in between, then waking up to fuck again.

"You should check your phone," Elara whispered.

"Why?" Asher asked, wondering if he had missed it ringing.

"You should have a surprise there."

"A surprise?" He reached for the phone on the nightstand, but it was turned off despite having been charging the whole night.

"Lucy asked me to turn it off, so we wouldn't get distracted when she would send you stuff," Elara explained, shifting so she could look at the screen too, while still pressed closely to him.

"What stuff?"

"She didn't tell," Elara replied. "But it's Lucy. Not hard to guess what that would be."

As his phone turned on, he actually had a lot of messages waiting, from Lucy, Rachel, Naomi, and Ava. Starting with the newest, he checked the ones from the fire mage.

Please delete whatever Lucy sent you with me involved

After you watch it

Except the group photo

And order Lucy to delete them too

Asher read through it, curiosity rising in him, wondering what Lucy could have sent him that was so embarrassing that Ava wanted them deleted. And yet, she still wanted him to see them at least once.

He didn't answer, first wanting to see what Lucy had sent him, but before that he opened his conversation with Rachel.

Don't forget to level up Sisi!!!

When are you going to a dungeon?

He quickly responded, assuring her he didn't forget, and they would need to prepare, but soon.

Left with messages from Naomi and Lucy, he chose the first one, as she had sent him only three, compared to many more from Lucy.

There was one photo, in which she was sitting on the floor in the living room. She looked really cute, her black hair framing her slightly reddened face as she smiled softly.

"She looks tipsy," Elara commented. Asher nodded, looking at the short message that was beneath.

I'm thinking about you

"Do you think she was dared to do it?" Elara asked.

"Yeah," Asher replied, and then turned his phone away from Elara's gaze.

"Hey," she gasped.

"The first sentence in the next message asks to not show it to anyone," Asher explained.

"It's just text," Elara said.

"Probably another dare, and she doesn't want you to see it," he replied, then looked at his phone, making sure that Elara couldn't see it.

Please don't show this to anyone. It's just a dare, and I'm supposed to tell you about a date. You don't have to do it, but I must write it.

We could take a walk through a park, eating ice cream and talking, and holding hands. Then maybe find a place where it's only us, no people around. Like a meadow, where we could lie down between the flowers and just watch the stars move across the sky, talking, cuddling, kissing and... maybe more.

But it's just a silly dream and a dare, so don't worry about it.

Asher read the message describing the date Naomi wanted, and it really wasn't anything difficult to do. She wrote about it as if it were complicated or expensive, telling him not to worry, while in truth it was very simple - he would only need to find the right place.

The last part, though, about "more," made him wonder if she really meant more. He could try to arrange it and find out. On the other hand, she had probably been tipsy and not completely aware of what she was writing. Either way, he could take her on a date like that, and he decided to plan something similar. The only problem was finding a meadow but he would just have to prepare for that.

"What was it?" Elara asked, when Asher shifted so she could see the screen again, after he closed the message from Naomi.

"She doesn't want you to know," he replied. "But now we can check Lucy's messages."

Elara pouted, but her expression quickly shifted - her eyes went wide and her mouth dropped as she stared at Asher's phone. He had scrolled to the first message of the night, and it was Ava kissing her fire elemental.

Look what you're missing

"Oh wow," Elara said.

"Yeah... It's not hard to guess who gave her that dare."

"But I'm surprised that she actually did it," Elara said.

"I'm not," Asher replied. "Ava is really... competitive. If Lucy knew how to press her buttons, she easily taunted her into a game like it was a competition. And it ends like that," he added, pointing at the phone.

Asher wondered how it would feel to kiss the elemental - if it was the same as with a human or very different. He would gladly help Ava if she were interested in experimenting more with her creations.

The next photo was from the bathroom, with Sisi in it. She held Asher's hoodie in front of her crotch, but otherwise she was naked. Her cheeks were darker than usual, her gaze turned aside, and a soft smile played on her lips. But his eyes were drawn lower, to her exposed chest.

Before, he had only groped her tits, never getting a good look at them. They were perky, and while they had felt small in his hands, on her thin frame they actually looked just right. Once again, a photo was followed by a message from Lucy.

Fancy some green tits?

"They really had some fun with those dares," Elara commented, looking at the photo.

Asher nodded, watching the dryad's tits, as his cock hardened, but then worry crept into his mind. How was Madelyn feeling with all of that happening? He couldn't imagine her being comfortable watching all of that. Or what would happen if someone dared her to do stuff like that.

The next one was quite a long video. They watched it with Elara without a word, his cock throbbing, getting even harder as he watched Lucy's bouncing tits, her pink hair disheveled and her flushed face as she ran naked around the house.

"You were right about Ava," Elara murmured after the video ended. "She took it as a competition."

"I really hope they focused on each other and didn't dare Maddy to do something bad," Asher said. Arousal mixed with worry as he found himself torn - wanting to check on Maddy, but also wanting to find Lucy and take her up on her offer from the video.

"She didn't send you anything, and wasn't in the photos so far," Elara replied, but as if to prove her wrong, Maddy was in the next one. But it was just a group one, of Ava, Naomi, Lucy, and Madelyn, standing together.

Naomi was turning toward Lucy, her face red and surprised. Asher wondered what Lucy had said or done to get a reaction like that. Ava just stood there awkwardly, looking like she had no idea what to do with herself.

And then there was Madelyn. As he had feared earlier, this photo left him a little confused, but also relieved. She seemed calm and at ease, especially without her usual hoodie. Dressed only in a shirt, with her hair loose, she looked so different from her normal self that Asher wondered if the change was part of a dare, or if she simply felt comfortable enough around the other girls to let her guard down.

The next one was a video from Lucy, just pointing at her face from above, showing a lot of cleavage. But the look wasn't important, rather what she had to say to him. Asher and Elara listened to the whole fantasy that she had described, clearly turning a dare from Ava against her.

While Asher smiled listening, and hearing Ava's frustrated tone in the background, Elara tensed at the mention of anal.

"Are you going to ask her?" Elara asked.

"We haven't done it so far," Asher replied, keeping in mind the rule that every first should be between them.

"I'm not sure if I want to do that," Elara said, frowning.

"You don't have to," Asher assured her.

"But maybe I would want to try one day. And then I would want it to be our first together."

"I can wait," Asher offered.

"And what if I never decide to do it?" Elara asked.

"I can live with that," he replied. "It... Well, given an opportunity it would be nice to at least try, but it's not like I'm gonna die if I never do it."

"I'll think about it," Elara murmured.

"Okay," Asher said, scrolling down to another video. This time it was Ava and her elemental, but rather than kissing, Ava knelt in front of it and licked her own creation's pussy, but it was hidden by the elemental's leg and hip.

"There's something hot in watching her do it," Elara said, then shifted her hand along Asher's body, until her fingers wrapped around his hard shaft, stroking it slowly up and down. "Seems you agree."

"Do you think she really liked it?" Asher asked.

"Yeah, she looked intrigued," Elara commented, still slowly jerking him off. Under the video there was another message.

It would be so much more fun with you here

He could only imagine what dares Lucy would come up with then. He doubted Madelyn could be present during that game.

The next and last photo was of Lucy - a mirror selfie in the bathroom. It was a big-eyed, puppy-dog look in human form. Her tits were out, her top bunched up beneath them as she squeezed her arms together, making her boobs look even better, while she stared at him sadly, as if pleading for something.

I'm really, really sorry

Please don't be super mad at me

Everyone's okay

"Fuck," Asher sighed, reading the messages beneath. He pulled away from his naked girlfriend, wanting to check what had happened.

"Can you handle this?" Elara asked. "I need to wash."

"Sure," he replied, leaving her in the bed after putting on some clothes quickly.

He was getting stressed that Lucy had dared Madelyn to do something that pushed her into another panic attack, and everything went bad. He stepped out of the room, wondering where he should look for them, but hearing some movement in the living room, he headed there first.

Naomi and Madelyn were both sitting on the couches, drinking tea. As he entered, both looked at him. Maddy was again in her hoodie, her hair in a ponytail. She smiled softly, but then bit her lip. Naomi, on the other hand, blushed and quickly averted her gaze.

"Hey," Asher said. "What happened?" Seeing that Madelyn was there and seemed fine, he was a little bit calmer, but something had happened.

"Why are you asking?" Naomi whispered.

"Lucy sent me a message during the night that she's sorry and to not be mad at her," he explained.

There was a moment of silence, as both girls looked at each other, as if hoping the other one would explain everything. "We played a truth or dare game," Naomi finally said. "And... drank a little and umm..."

"Some dare go too far?" Asher asked, when she trailed off.

After a bit of hesitation Naomi shook her head, and when Asher looked at Madelyn, who was still chewing on her lower lip, she also shook her head.

"Umm... Maybe we drank a bit more than a little," Naomi said. "And maybe Lucy gave some alcohol to Sisi. And maybe she kind of... drank too much. And maybe she wasn't feeling so great later on?"

"Maddy?" Asher asked, looking at his blonde friend, hoping for an explanation that would not contain so many maybes.

"She's okay now," Madelyn replied. "She... puked most of what she drank," she whispered. "And she was feeling better later on. Now she sleeps."

"She was puking?!" Asher gasped.

Both girls nodded.

"I told Lucy that Sisi shouldn't drink," he said, with frustration growing in him. Lucy had completely ignored him and had done whatever she wanted. And just as he had been worried, it went bad.

No one replied anything to that. "Is everyone else okay?" Asher asked, wondering if all of them drank too much.

"Yeah," Madelyn replied.

"So only Sisi got drunk?" Asher asked, wondering how they let the dryad get to the point of puking while the rest of them were okay.

"Umm... I wouldn't say so," Madelyn replied, quickly glancing at Naomi, before she averted her gaze.

"I might have fallen asleep on the couch," Naomi mumbled, not looking at Asher. "And have a little headache, but I'll be okay soon," she added quickly.

"Are you okay, Maddy?" Asher asked, with concern clear in his voice.

"Yeah, I barely drank anything."

"Good," he replied. "What about the others?"

"Sam went to bed when she got tired, and she was downstairs not long ago. Now she's in her room and is okay," Nami said. "Ava..." she trailed off again, her cheeks blushing.

"Ava what?" Asher asked, wondering if something had happened or if it was because of her getting intimate with her elementals.

"She drank a lot," Madelyn replied. "But she seemed... okay, and not drunk. I mean, she was a bit... a lot less reserved than normal. But when Sisi began to feel bad, and Nami went to sleep, Ava just went upstairs to her room," she explained, blushing too.

"Was Lucy okay?" Asher asked.

"She and Ava drank the most, but she seemed okay, and..." Nami trailed off again.

Asher barely stopped himself from letting out a sigh, having a hard time learning something from both shy and blushing girls. "And?"

"Not important," Naomi replied, shaking her head. "But Lucy is... she's really sorry."

"Where is Sisi?" Asher asked.

"With Lucy in her room, sleeping," Nami replied.

Asher sighed, wondering what he was supposed to do. He wanted to check on the others, how they felt, but unsure if they were still asleep or awake, he decided to first have a private talk with Madelyn.

"Maddy, can we talk?" he asked.

"Sure," she replied, placing her tea on the table and following him to the kitchen.

"Are you okay?" Asher asked. "I'm not talking about the alcohol, but I saw the photos and videos, and it seemed the night got a little wild."

"Yeah," Madelyn replied, her pale cheeks with a slight blush. "I'm okay. It's... The girls were really nice, and Lucy made sure that I was comfortable, and they went easy on me with dares. Have you asked them to do it?" she asked.

"Yeah," Asher replied. "I didn't say anything to them, but just asked them to remember that you're not part of our team."

Madelyn nodded, with the blush spreading further on her cheeks.

"So, you had fun?" Asher asked.

"Y-Yeah," she replied. "It's... When I think about it now, I'm like..." she didn't finish but shook her head. "But somehow during the night, it seemed okay. I-I mean, I would never be able to do some of those things they did, but... I don't know, I kind of felt a bit like an observer watching it, and I had fun."

"I'm glad you liked it," Asher said.

Madelyn nodded slowly, looking at him and chewing her lip. Her eyes glistened with tears, and he was going to ask what happened, but to his surprise, she suddenly moved forward and hugged him. "Thank you," she mumbled, wrapping her hands around his body, pressing herself into his chest.

Asher was shocked by her initiating contact and being so close to him. He slowly put his hands high on her back, hugging her gently.

"You don't have to thank me," he replied. "Lucy organized everything."

"You asked her to invite me," Madelyn whispered. "She wouldn't do it without you. And even if she did, I-I would never agree without you convincing me. And... And I would still be sitting alone in my room, most likely crying. And yesterday I felt... normal for a moment."

Tears were streaming down Madelyn's face, but she snorted a laugh. "I was super embarrassed a lot, and in shock at what they were actually doing, but on the other hand, like... like a normal girl just having fun with her girlfriends, not like someone who's broken and fucked up."

Asher was glad that she liked the girls' night so much, but was also worried about her using such harsh words toward herself. It was so unfair, what had happened to her, and how it influenced her whole life, because some pathetic asshole hurt her for a short moment of his own satisfaction.

As he hugged her tighter, thinking about it, he realized that this hug, with how close they were, was not so friendly anymore, and more... something strange, that wasn't just a hug between friends.

Madelyn suddenly pulled back, and he immediately let go of her as she stepped away. "Umm..." she muttered, her cheeks blushing, and Asher realized that she was thinking the same about their hug.

"T-There's something I want to ask," she whispered, when Asher was still confused about the whole situation with her.

"Go on," he prompted.

"L-Lucy offered that... I can come visit here whenever I want," Maddy whispered. "I-I don't want to intrude, but I don't know... Lucy seems nice. Naomi... During the game, it was a bit weird, but we talked and she's really cool too. Ava's a bit... bitchy? Sam is distant. I don't understand Sisi. I don't know if Elara likes me. But... but while it doesn't sound so good, it... I don't know, it seems better to be here than alone in my room. Especially that... you're here," she whispered the last part. "I don't know why, but somehow I feel okay, just kind of sitting at the side and watching. So I thought that maybe I could come and hang out here from time to time if that's not a problem?"

"Of course," Asher replied, without really needing to think about it. "But you do realize that with my class, and the nature of my team, the atmosphere here might be... quite open?"

"I-I know," Madelyn replied, blushing. "B-But... it's not like you are gonna do it in the living room, right?"

"Umm..." Asher hesitated.

"Oh..." Madelyn said. "Y-You already did?"

"We can make a safe zone in the living room," he offered, and then began chuckling at the whole concept of that.

"N-No," Madelyn replied. "It's your home, I don't want to intrude."

"You won't," Asher replied. "Besides, it's not like we're going to do things all the time, so just let me know when you're coming and going, and it'll be fine. You can hang out here as much as you want."

"T-Thanks."

"About what you said," Asher said. "Why do you think that Elara doesn't like you?"

"I-I didn't say that," Madelyn replied. "B-But, like, we're friends, right?"

"Of course," Asher replied, frowning.

"But I'm not friends with her. We just know each other through you, so I don't talk with her, or anything. I don't know if she would be okay with me around," Madelyn explained.

"She will be," Asher replied. "Don't worry. If you ask Elara to hang out and do something together, she would love to do it. Actually, can I ask you for a favor?"

Madelyn nodded, chewing on her lip. Asher wanted to stop her but restrained himself, as that would really be too intimate contact between friends.

"Elara doesn't have any friends here. We have our team, but... I think it would be good if she would hang out with someone outside of us from time to time, so you could do something with her. What do you think?"

"I-I can ask," Madelyn replied.

"I would be really grateful," Asher said, smiling. But then his thoughts returned to what Madelyn had said about another of the girls. "Was Ava bitchy toward you?" he asked.

"No!" Madelyn gasped. "She was like that toward Lucy, but I think it's just... friendly teasing. With me... she was nice."

"Okay, once again, I'm glad you had fun," Asher said.

After that, they returned to the living room. While he wanted to just sit down and hang out with them, the need to check on the rest of his harem members was too strong.

Not wanting to talk with Lucy, he decided to check on Ava. She was already awake, as she invited him into her room after he knocked on her door. She was lying on her bed under the cover, but as she sat up, the blanket fell, greeting him with a view of her tits.